What counts as inequality?
Any claim about gender inequality makes choices, often without saying so. This board makes them visible.
- Which outcomes count. Earnings and leadership are standard measures. Life expectancy, imprisonment and deaths on the job are often left out.
- Which direction counts. Some indexes only count gaps where women are behind.
- Gaps or levels. A gap can stay about the same while both groups get much better off (heart disease deaths) or much worse off (overdose deaths).
- When you look. A gap that is “stuck” over five years may have closed dramatically over forty.
- Which data exist. Many of the measures on this board have no comparable figure from around 1980. Some surveys started later (the federal time-use survey began in 2003), some changed their methods, and some results weren’t reported separately for women and men, so older numbers can’t always be lined up with newer ones. What gets tracked over time reflects what researchers and governments thought was worth counting, so the long-run picture rests on fewer measures than today’s.
- Averages or groups. A national average for “women” or “men” can hide large differences by race, class, age and place.
- Outcomes or treatment. A gap in outcomes doesn't by itself show unfair treatment, and equal outcomes don't prove fair treatment.
Talk about it
- Before you revealed anything, did you expect most knots to move to one side? Which result surprised you most?
- Switch the year to “All years” to see each row change from around 1980 to today. Which gaps closed, which reversed, and which barely moved?
- With “All years” on, click “Show all measures.” Which kinds of measures have no figure from around 1980? Why might no one have tracked them then, or tracked them in a way we can compare today?
- Use the Topic buttons to look at one area at a time. Which topics lean toward women, and which toward men?
- Open the extra measures in “Education.” How does the overall balance change? Who decides which measures belong on the board?
- Use the ×1 buttons to weight the measures you care about most. Which three would you weight most heavily, and why? Compare with a classmate.
- Try “Only where women are behind,” then “Only where men are behind.” Real indexes make choices like this. What does each choice assume about what inequality is?
- Averages for “women” and “men” hide big differences by race, class, age, and region. Pick one row and predict how it might change for a specific group.
- A gap tells you that groups differ, not why. For one row, list two possible explanations a sociologist would want to test.
How to read the board
Each knot’s distance from the middle shows how far apart women and men are on one measure, as a percentage: the smaller number is this much below the larger one. If women earn 81 cents for each dollar men earn, the gap is 19%. If men are four times as likely to die by homicide, the gap is 75%.
The side and color show who comes out ahead. For some measures higher is better (life expectancy, earnings). For others lower is better (homicide, poverty). A few have no obvious “better” direction, so their knots stay gray in the middle until you choose.
Why are some shares “better” and others gray? A bigger share of all degrees, or of seats in Congress, means more education or more power for that group. A share of one field is different: more women in computer science means fewer men there, and the pay effects already show up in the earnings row. Whether a field split is a problem depends on why it exists, so you decide.
Test scores are on scales without a true zero, so their rows compare the score difference to the spread of scores (the standard deviation) instead.
The overall balance at the top is a weighted average of the gaps for the rows you’ve revealed. It’s a thinking tool, not a published measure.
In “All years,” each row shows its knots for around 1980, around 2000, and the latest data, top to bottom, joined by a line. A missing knot means there’s no comparable figure for that period. The overall balance then compares only rows with figures for all three periods, so it doesn’t shift just because rows drop in and out of the data.
Why this matters
Real indexes of gender equality have to choose measures, weights, and rules. The World Economic Forum’s Global Gender Gap Index, for example, caps each score at parity, so areas where women are ahead don’t count toward the total. Other researchers have built indexes that count gaps in both directions, and critics have challenged their choices too.
Neither approach is simply right. Each one answers a different question. That is the point to take away: “Is there gender inequality?” is really several questions, and the answer depends on which ones you ask.
Other fields help here. Economists separate the raw pay gap from the gap that remains after accounting for jobs and hours. Public health researchers study why men die younger. Criminologists track who commits violence as well as who experiences it.