By Gwen Sharp · @gsharpokie

Who Counts as What?

Every U.S. census since 1790 has asked about race, and the choices have changed almost every time. Click through the years to see what the categories were, who got to decide, and why they changed. If race were a fixed, biological fact, the boxes wouldn’t keep moving.

The census, year by year

Same person, different census

Pick a person. Nothing about them changes, but how the government recorded their race does.

    Talk about it

    1. The same person born in Mexico was recorded as “Mexican” in 1930 and as “White” in 1940. What does that tell you about whether race is biological or social?
    2. Until 1960, census takers usually decided a person’s race. Now people decide for themselves. Why might those two methods give different answers for the same person?
    3. Pick one year. Who chose the categories, and whose interests did they serve?
    4. Some people argue a government committed to treating everyone equally shouldn’t ask about race at all. Others argue you can’t track or fix inequality you don’t measure. What are the strongest points on each side?

    Sources

    Quotes from historical instructions use their original wording, including terms that are offensive today. Categories are shown as the census used them; labels for years without a full list show only what was added or dropped.

    How to cite this page

    Sharp, Gwen. 2026. “Who Counts as What?” https://gsharpokie.github.io/whocountsaswhat/

    Spot an error? Suggest a correction (needs a free GitHub account).